How US wasted billions on absurd errors in Afghanistan conflict

For nearly twenty years, the U.S. army has siphoned a lot blood, sweat, and tears into combating the insurgencies littering Afghanistan.

Within the coming weeks, the Pentagon plans to speed up the troop drawdown from 4,500 to 2,500 beneath orders from President Trump – abandoning a bleak image of a struggling nation beleaguered by almost each day assaults, bullet-pockmarked buildings and an ailing financial system.

All through the years of the Afghan conflict effort, American taxpayers have footed the invoice – on common about $3,000 every – with a complete price ticket succeeding $1 trillion. Roughly $138 billion in taxpayer {dollars} alone have been disseminated for Afghan aid and reconstruction.


Of that, a staggering $19 billion fell to the wayside of waste between 2009 and 2019 alone, in response to the Workplace of the Particular Inspector Common for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR).

“SIGAR has recognized almost $20 billion in waste. I think that quantity is far increased, SIGAR has solely audited about one half of the $134 billion in support supplied since 2002,” Invoice Roggio, Senior Fellow, Basis for Protection of Democracies (FDD) and editor of the Lengthy Struggle Journal, instructed Fox Information. “Cash (was thrown) on the downside within the hope (to) repair it. This merely fed the corrupt politicians, bureaucrats, army and police officers, and others who’re in no brief demand.”

A person, wounded after gunmen stormed Kabul college, arrives in an ambulance to Isteqlal Hospital in Kabul on November 2, 2020. – Gunmen stormed Kabul college on November 2 forward of the opening of an Iranian e-book honest, firing pictures and sending college students fleeing, Afghan officers and witnesses stated. (Picture by WAKIL KOHSAR / AFP) (Picture by WAKIL KOHSAR/AFP by way of Getty Photographs)

Like in a single case, about $10 billion was spent on principally counter-narcotics and stabilization initiatives. Nonetheless, the Center Japanese nation nonetheless provides greater than 80% of the world’s heroin and opium, in addition to meth.

In the meantime, about $500 billion has been clocked up in curiosity, given {that a} outstanding portion of the battle was waged on borrowed funds.

In mid-2018, a SIGAR report bluntly acknowledged that “giant sums of U.S. stabilization {dollars} typically exacerbated conflicts, enabled corruption, and bolstered assist for insurgents.” Years earlier, it careworn that additional motion was wanted to “utterly confirm payroll prices and workforce energy” with the Afghan Forces personnel programs.

“Regardless of 13 years and billions of {dollars} in wage help to the Afghan authorities for the Afghan Nationwide Military (ANA), there may be nonetheless no assurance that personnel and payroll information are correct,” SIGAR auditors wrote in a 2014 audit. “There are not any necessities that supervisory ANA officers observe attendance information assortment at lower-level models.” 

The report revealed that when it got here to the Afghan Nationwide Police alone, “greater than $300 million in annual, U.S.-funded wage funds is predicated on partially verified or reconciled information.”


An investigation into the so-called “ghost soldier” difficulty in 2019 revealed that simply as investigators vowed to do one other crackdown on it, all of a sudden, 42,000 Afghan troops and law enforcement officials disappeared from the payroll. A report printed in late August 2020 discovered that “50% to 70% of police positions have been ‘ghost troopers,’” referring to personnel listed on the books who don’t exist.  

SIGAR uncovered different flagrant blunders – just like the $28 million spent on Afghan military uniforms in 2017, which was later criticized on condition that the gear chosen was deemed solely appropriate for environments “so uncommon they account for simply 2% of Afghanistan’s countryside.”

Furthermore, a lot of the condemnation surrounding the U.S. marketing campaign in Afghanistan has stemmed from the flurry of alternatives that opened for contractors – each U.S. and Afghan nationals – to illicitly revenue from the clean checks with inadequate vetting and oversight.

From 2012 to 2015, the U.S. Division of Justice took on a minimum of eight circumstances centered on mass bribery, fraud, and conspiracy to steal American monies in Afghanistan, as per public court docket filings. But, the issue continued.

March 27, 2020: Municipality workers bury the body of coronavirus victim on the outskirts of Herat province west of Kabul, Afghanistan. Across the Middle East and parts of South Asia, bereaved families have faced traumatic restrictions on burying their dead amid the pandemic. Religion and customs that require speedy burials in the largely Muslim region have clashed with fears of COVID-19 contagion and government-mandated lockdowns. (AP Photo/Hamed Sarfarazi)

March 27, 2020: Municipality staff bury the physique of coronavirus sufferer on the outskirts of Herat province west of Kabul, Afghanistan. Throughout the Center East and elements of South Asia, bereaved households have confronted traumatic restrictions on burying their lifeless amid the pandemic. Faith and customs that require speedy burials within the largely Muslim area have clashed with fears of COVID-19 contagion and government-mandated lockdowns. (AP Picture/Hamed Sarfarazi)


A number of circumstances in recent times have proven U.S. authorities contractors in Afghanistan being sentenced to jail for “accepting unlawful kickbacks” from Afghan subcontractors in return for help in acquiring subcontracts.

The latest case got here simply final month when a former CEO of a U.S. authorities contractor in Alabama was charged in reference to schemes to defraud the U.S. Division of Protection relating to contracts associated to U.S. army efforts in Afghanistan,” allegedly partaking in two fraudulent schemes between 2013 and 2017. 

And it’s not simply contractors – active-duty U.S. troops have additionally been implicated in a minimum of 22 fraud-related schemes in Afghanistan, in response to Division of Protection filings. These different from convictions of a U.S. soldier working in cohorts with locals to smuggle nearly $290,000 price of provides to be bought off-base to a U.S. Military Corps of Engineers soliciting $320,000 in bribes from contractors “in return for help” in U.S. authorities contracts, to an Military Reserve captain soliciting $1.Three million in bribes and “conspiring to site visitors heroin” and one other soldier bulk money smuggling in extra of $1 million.

When it comes to the mismanagement of funds, SIGAR reviews have additionally illuminated squandered {dollars} at army and police coaching amenities.

In a single occasion in 2016, SIGAR famous that the U.S. Military Corps of Engineers awarded a $3.1 million firm-fixed-price to Help Consultants Inc. to design and construct a compound to coach 100 feminine college students within the Afghan Nationwide Police. An audit three years later confirmed that the compound had no electrical energy and had by no means been used.

Audits have additionally proven points with the printing and distribution of faculty books, regardless of the thousands and thousands shelled out for the trigger. A September 2019 watchdog letter acknowledged that whereas the U.S. Company for Worldwide Improvement had been funding the Afghan faculty program since 2002, in 2009, the Afghanistan Ministry of Schooling (MoE) initiated a revised curriculum for basic and Islamic schooling. 

“Based mostly on that curriculum, new textbooks for primary schooling have been printed and distributed with the assist of USAID and different growth companions,” the report continued. “Nonetheless, we discovered e-book high quality deficiencies, comparable to free or clean pages, misspellings, and low-quality paper. Principals and lecturers at 1 / 4 of the colleges inspected acknowledged, ‘that the books have been now not in usable situation.'”

Faculties themselves throughout the beleaguered nation have additionally been plagued with the identical dilemmas for years on-end, bringing into query simply how a lot of the greater than $1.1 billion USAID has disbursed successfully went to “enhancing the standard of Afghanistan’s schooling system.”

“From October 2015 to October 2018, we visited 171 colleges in 10 provinces all through Afghanistan and issued 10 reviews and Four alert letters addressing the situation of these colleges,” SIGAR stated. “We discovered that lots of the colleges had structural deficiencies (e.g., confirmed indicators of settlement or deterioration, cracks or giant holes of their roofs, and broken or eliminated home windows and doorways) that might probably influence security and the supply of schooling.”

 Jan. 31, 2020:Marine Gen. Frank McKenzie, center, top U.S. commander for the Middle East, makes an unannounced visit in Kabul, Afghanistan. Six months after a deadly American airstrike in Baghdad enraged Iraqis and fueled demands to send all U.S. troops home, McKenzie is talking optimistically about keeping a smaller, but enduring military presence in Iraq. (AP Photos/Lolita Baldor)

 Jan. 31, 2020:Marine Gen. Frank McKenzie, heart, high U.S. commander for the Center East, makes an unannounced go to in Kabul, Afghanistan. Six months after a lethal American airstrike in Baghdad enraged Iraqis and fueled calls for to ship all U.S. troops residence, McKenzie is speaking optimistically about preserving a smaller, however enduring army presence in Iraq. (AP Photographs/Lolita Baldor)

Elsewhere, points percolating round visa charges are additionally stated to be a supply of the U.S. greenback swindling in Afghanistan. In July 2020, SIGAR notified the U.S. State Division and the Pentagon over protracted issues ensuing within the lack of thousands and thousands

“In Might and June 2013, SIGAR printed two reviews addressing burdensome and wasteful insurance policies, together with acquiring visas, that U.S. contractors confronted when implementing reconstruction initiatives in Afghanistan (and) reported that visa procedures could possibly be costing the U.S. authorities greater than $1,100 per contractor per 12 months,” Sopko wrote. “(The) Afghan Authorities has levied almost a billion {dollars} in enterprise taxes on contractors supporting U.S. authorities efforts in Afghanistan, (and) the U.S. authorities lacked a unified coverage addressing Afghan Authorities charges charged to reconstruction contractors.”

Alexandra Abrams, communications director for Residents Towards Authorities Waste, instructed Fox Information that every 12 months SIGAR reviews spotlight new wasted spending within the Center Japanese nation, and nothing appears to alter.

“The expertise in Afghanistan has demonstrated a elementary incapability of U.S. businesses to coordinate growth efforts,” she stated. “The troublesome safety scenario within the nation contributed to all these issues, however the U.S. by no means appeared to study from its errors.”


Nonetheless, the united statesand different international donors final month agreed to provide Kabul an extra $Three billion for 2021 – contingent on their continuation of peace talks with the Taliban – of which the U.S. has made accessible $600 million. A complete dedication of $12 billion over the following 4 years was reached, falling shy of the greater than $15 billion pledged simply previous to President Trump taking workplace.

However Afghanistan’s future–and whether or not the incoming Biden administration will proceed to detangle itself financially from the beleaguered nation – stays to be seen.

“If the U.S. completes the withdrawal from Afghanistan, then one greenback can be an excessive amount of. Contended,” Roggio added. “U.S. support to Afghanistan has been grossly mismanaged with a U.S. presence, and there can be no approach to make sure it was spent properly with out a U.S. presence.”

Leave a Comment